Case Study: From Dot-Com Failure to an $8M Exit: The Webmail.us Story
How a founder rebuilt from burnout, debt, and a collapsing market to build a category-defining product.
Introduction
Before becoming a Rackspace-acquired success story, Pat Matthews went through two painful startup failures, financial stress, and a dot-com collapse that nearly wiped him out. What ultimately emerged was Webmail.us, a focused, bootstrapped, and customer-obsessed email hosting company that grew from a basement in Virginia to thousands of business customers and an $8M revenue run rate.
This case study breaks down Matthews’ journey, his pivots, the strategy behind Webmail.us, and the lessons founders can apply today.
The Founder’s Journey: From Dot-Com Collapse to Basement Startup
In 2000, during the height of the dot-com boom, Virginia Tech student Pat Matthews dropped out in his senior year to build a user-generated content platform. This was years before the UGC became mainstream.
The first idea: local event content from the community
The team raised ~$40–50K from friends and family and built a platform for people to post local events. It generated buzz in Blacksburg, but users weren’t ready. Posting your own content online was not normal yet.
They tried manually seeding content and even hired marketing reps to gather local data, but the model was unscalable. And then the dot-com crash hit.
Investor interest disappeared overnight. Even though they raised another $100K from friends and family, the company couldn’t gain traction. Matthews described the period as “gut-wrenching” sleepless nights, no revenue, and taking part-time jobs to survive.
Pivot #1: SaaS for local publishers
In 2001, the team pivoted their software into a SaaS platform for newspapers. But each customer required heavy customization, and the newspaper industry was deteriorating financially. Burnout hit. Matthews and co-founder Bill even rotated back into college to finish their degrees while keeping the business alive.
The breakthrough: businesses only wanted the email hosting
Clients kept asking for just one feature, the email hosting layer. Matthews noticed the signal, leaned into it, and executed his biggest pivot yet:
Focus entirely on business email hosting and rebrand as Webmail.us.
He moved into the basement office full-time, lived cheaply, hired five more employees, and built a business with thousands of paying customers including the first Fortune 500 account.
This was the model that finally worked! like this Coffee
Elevate your coffee experience with fresh-roasted, ethically sourced beans
Small batch, specialty-grade coffee shipped to your door. Scientifically proven to taste like good decisions. Every bag is roasted to order! Try Now
Strategy: What Made Webmail.us Win
1. Ruthless Focus on One Painful Problem
After failing twice by trying to solve too much, Matthews committed to a single product: reliable business email hosting with strong spam and virus protection.
While Hotmail/Yahoo chased millions of free consumer accounts, Webmail.us targeted businesses willing to pay for reliability.
Focus became a core philosophy:
“Just because you can do everything doesn’t mean you should.”
2. Customer-Centric Premium Service
Businesses valued uptime, security, and support. Webmail.us positioned itself as:
premium over free competitors
focused exclusively on business needs
accessible, reliable, and high-touch
This differentiated them in a space dominated by consumer players.
3. Bootstrapping Discipline
The company raised only $130K initially, then a later $500K. Matthews lived where he worked. Every dollar went into servers, engineering, and customer support.
They operated near break-even while growing steadily. Lean operations became an advantage.
4. World-Class Infrastructure (Even From a Basement)
Even though the team worked in a basement, they hosted all production servers at Rackspace to guarantee uptime and credibility. This set the stage for:
a strong technical reputation
a partnership
and eventually, an acquisition
5. Adaptability: Pivot, Pivot, Pivot
Matthews’ superpower became his willingness to pivot quickly when the market spoke.
UGC → didn’t work (too early)
SaaS platform → unscalable
Email hosting → clear, painful business problem
He embraced the insight:
“Timing is really critical, and we were definitely ahead of our time.”
Milestones & Financial Highlights
2000–2001: Raised $130K across two failing ventures.
2002: Pivot to email hosting → Webmail.us is born.
Early traction: Thousands of SMBs + first Fortune 500 customer.
First major milestone: $200K ARR (the “hardest” revenue according to Matthews).
Later traction:
Reached $1M annual sales (big internal celebration)
$8M revenue run-rate by 2007
2007: Acquired by Rackspace (near 100% stock deal).
Post-acquisition: Email & Apps division grew from 50 → 250 employees across VA & San Antonio.
Lessons for Founders
1. Timing can make or break you
Being early is the same as being wrong. UGC in 2000 was simply too early.
2. Focus is a superpower
Trying to build multiple products nearly killed the company. One focused product; email hosting that created an $8M business.
3. Revenue > Vanity metrics
The dot-com era prioritized growth over revenue. Matthews learned the hard way:
Revenue discipline is survival.
4. Failure strengthens the entrepreneur
The emotional toll of failure created sharper judgment and deeper resilience.
“Once you taste that failure, success feels that much better.”
5. Passion sustains you
Matthews survived because he and his co-founder were deeply passionate; one about business, the other about technology. Passion powered persistence.
Post-Acquisition: New Battles
After being acquired, Matthews led Rackspace’s Email & Apps division. He now faced:
managing distributed teams
competing with Google and Microsoft
hitting financial performance targets
scaling from a basement startup to a 250-person organization
Even with financial security, he admits he’s still wired like a founder:
He can’t turn his mind off. The drive to build remains.
FounderPedia’s Take
Pat Matthews’ story is one of grit, reinvention, and extreme focus. Webmail.us succeeded because he listened to the market, doubled down on one high-value need, and ran a disciplined operation from day one. His journey shows:
Failure = tuition
Focus = leverage
Adaptability = survival
Passion = fuel
It’s a blueprint for founders navigating uncertain markets!
Founders who love coffee could elevate their coffee experience with fresh-roasted, ethically sourced beans of specialty-grade coffee here
The pivot from SaaS for newspapers to just email hosting is classic. Customers kept asking for one feature and he actualy listened. Thats how you bootstrap properly, focus on what people will actully pay for.